3013.22 In PS17/23, the PRA noted that positions in scope of the RRAO were subject to risks – potentially material – that are not captured elsewhere in the market risk framework. It follows that fully exempting instruments could leave risks uncapitalised, which would be inconsistent with the PRA’s primary objective. While the PRA also acknowledges the permissions regime may lead to some variation in approaches across firms, where differences arise, these should reflect firms’ own risk assessment and therefore appropriately align with how they manage those risks. Where firms identify that the residual risk is immaterial, the outcomes should not be materially different from jurisdictions that choose to exempt a list of products.
3033.23 With regard to concerns over operational burden, while the PRA expects the methodology proposed by firms to be subjected to comparable internal governance and review processes that would be expected for an internal model, the RRAO application process will be separate from the internal models review. Given the approach is expected to apply only to a small number of material instruments, the application burden would be proportionate to the materiality of the risks. The PRA can also clarify that the permissions regime will operate on an ongoing basis, with permissions granted for each type of instrument to cover all current and future exposures to that instrument. Firms will be required to make a one-off application, identifying instruments within the scope of the RRAO where they can demonstrate that the RRAO is disproportionate. This one-off process per instrument ensures that ongoing operational burden remain minimal beyond the initial application.
3053.24 Respondents also asked for clarification on the application process, including interaction with Pillar 2 requirements, and the interpretation of the rules related to offsetting in the RRAO.
3073.25 To provide greater clarity and transparency on the approvals process, the PRA has updated the Permissions (CRR firms) webpage with documents setting out the format and content of the supporting information expected for Permissions applications to use alternative RRAO calculation, including expected timelines for approval.
3093.26 With regard to offsetting of positions in the calculation of the RRAO, the PRA has clarified in Article 325u(4)(a) of the Market Risk: Advanced Standardised Approach (CRR) Part that firms can offset positions in the same instrument where the instruments are identical in all respects except for their notional amount, provided the offsetting position is with a third party. The PRA also expects firms to incorporate any relevant changes into their Pillar 2A calculation as a result of applying for the permission.
3133.27 The PRA proposed to make consequential amendments to the reporting and disclosure requirements to align with the proposals above. In particular, the PRA proposed to:
319update reporting and disclosure templates that cross-refer to the FRTB-IMA and replace these with references to the existing IMA for the period to Saturday 1 January 2028.
325the aggregation of reporting and disclosure requirements for PRA supervised firms with entities operating under different jurisdictions, particularly where some jurisdictions have not yet implemented Basel 3.1.
3273.29 Having considered the responses, the PRA has decided to implement the proposals as consulted on. The PRA has updated the market risk ASA reporting instructions to clarify the reporting requirements for firms with an interest rate internal hedge portfolio. The PRA notes that PRA-supervised firms with entities across different jurisdictions can find details of aggregation requirements in the Reporting (CRR) Part, and Disclosure (CRR) Part respectively.
3313.30 In addition to responses linked to the CP proposals, the PRA also received comments requesting clarification on the PRA near-final rules related to the FRTB, and other broader comments that were outside the scope of this consultation.
3333.31 Two respondents requested clarification on the treatment of To-be-Announced (TBAs) and deliverable pools eligible as Uniform Mortgage-Backed Securities (UMBS) under the ASA. The PRA can clarify that firms should treat Federal National Mortgage Association (Fannie Mae), Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation (Freddie Mac), and the Federal Home Loan Bank System as separate obligors. As the single security initiative led by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac has homogenized the mortgage pool and security characteristics for UMBS, the PRA can also clarify that firms may treat TBAs and deliverable pools eligible as UMBS as a single name issuer, either to Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac, when applying the ASA.
3353.32 Three respondents provided comments on the FRTB-IMA. The PRA notes that CP17/25 proposed a delay to the FRTB-IMA but did not at this stage suggest any changes while the PRA await greater clarity on the implementation plans in other jurisdictions. These areas are therefore outside the scope of the proposals in CP17/25, and the PRA has decided not to address them here.
3373.33 Five respondents provided a range of other comments on technical adjustments to aspects of the ASA beyond those proposed in CP17/25, some of which were also raised and considered as part of developing the near-final rules. These are outside the scope of the consultation, and the PRA has therefore decided not to make these changes.
3413.34 The PRA considers that the assessment of its statutory objectives and the ‘have regards’ analysis due to the changes to the de minimis threshold for the LTA eligibility under the ASA and the clarification on the RRAO offsetting provision made above are materially consistent with the assessment set out in CP17/25. The PRA therefore considers that the assessment of its statutory objectives and the ‘have regards’ analysis presented in CP17/25 remains appropriate.
3453.35 The PRA has also made minor amendments, corrections and clarifications to the policy, rules, and supervisory statements published as near-final in PS17/23. These include:
347The CRR risk weight for credit spread risk for non-securitisations and securitisations for the UK central government and Bank of England in Articles 325ah and 325ak of the Market Risk: Advanced Standardised Approach (CRR) Part, which has been re-instated to correct its unintentional omission in the near-final rules.
3514.1 This chapter provides feedback to responses to CP17/23 – Capitalisation of foreign exchange positions for market risk, which set out the PRA’s proposed clarifications and amendments when capitalising foreign exchange (FX) exposures under the market risk framework. The PRA proposed that the changes would be implemented at the same time as Basel 3.1. This chapter also sets out the PRA’s final policy on capitalisation of FX positions for market risk following the consultation.
355to make changes to Article 325 of the proposed Market Risk: General Provisions (CRR) Part of the PRA Rulebook to clarify that items held on the balance sheet at historical FX rates are not to be included as a risk position for the purposes of calculating Pillar 1 capital requirements for market risk;
357that firms should take account of, and where necessary capitalise, the contingent FX risk arising from positions held at historical FX rates in the Internal Capital Adequacy Assessment Process (ICAAP) Pillar 2 calculations under the Internal Capital Adequacy Assessment (ICAA) Part of the PRA Rulebook;
359to amend Article 325(9) of the proposed Market Risk: General Provisions (CRR) Part of the PRA Rulebook and SS13/13 – Market Risk to set out the types of positions which firms can exclude from the calculation of own funds requirements for foreign exchange risk where they have a permission under Article 325(9) to do so (an ‘SFX Permission’);footnote [10]
361to set out expectations in SS13/13 on the calculation of the maximum net FX risk position and the overall net FX position for the own funds calculation for firms with an SFX Permission; and
3654.3 The PRA received five responses to the proposals. Three respondents welcomed the PRA’s proposal to clarify capitalisation of FX positions under the market risk framework. All respondents asked for further clarification in some areas. Comments focused on:
3754.4 Having considered the responses, the PRA has decided to amend the draft rules and expectations in certain areas. This chapter describes the comments and amendments that the PRA considers are more material. The PRA has also made a number of non-substantive amendments and clarifications, which are not described in this chapter. All amendments are reflected in the appendices to this PS.
379amend Article 325 (Approaches for Calculating the Own Funds Requirements for Market Risk) in the Market Risk: General Provisions (CRR) Part of the PRA Rulebook (see Appendix 1);
3854.6 The sections below have been structured broadly along the same lines as CP17/23, covering the main areas where the PRA received comments from respondents, as follows:
3954.7 In CP17/23, the PRA proposed to clarify that positions held at historical FX rates in accordance with the relevant accounting principles are not to be included in the calculation of own funds requirements for market risk as these positions do not typically affect capital ratios. The PRA proposed to achieve this by amending Article 325 of the Market Risk: General Provisions (CRR) Part of the PRA Rulebook. The PRA proposed that this would apply to all market risk calculation approaches, including the SSA, ASA and IMA. The PRA noted that it considers that firms should take account of, and where necessary capitalise, the contingent FX arising from these positions in the ICAAP Pillar 2 calculations under the ICAA Part of the PRA Rulebook.
3974.8 The PRA received two responses to these proposals. Both respondents welcomed the PRA’s proposal that positions held at historical FX rates in accordance with the relevant accounting principles are not to be included in the calculation of own funds requirements for market risk. One respondent pointed out that some adjustments may be needed to cover situations where an item is held at historical cost on the entity balance sheet but retranslated in the consolidated balance sheet. Both respondents asked for further detail on how the assessment of contingent FX would work under Pillar 2.
3994.9 Having considered the responses, the PRA has updated SS13/13 to provide additional guidance in paragraph 3B.2A on how the requirements to exclude certain items held at historical FX rates from the Pillar 1 market risk calculation are to be applied.