4014.10 The PRA has also amended the rule requiring positions held at historical cost to be excluded from the Pillar 1 market risk calculation, to better reflect its policy intent, as follows:
403to clarify that items held at historical FX rates should be excluded from the calculation of own funds requirements for foreign exchange risk (not the calculation of own funds requirements of all aspects of market risk);
405to remove the criteria which specified that items must only be excluded if they are subject to the risk of impairment due to foreign exchange risk, as retaining this would preclude the exclusion of liability or equity items held at historical cost; and
4134.12 In CP17/23, the PRA proposed to replace its expectation on firms seeking an SFX Permission that they segregate their SFX positions from other trading activities, with a requirement for firms to do so. The PRA also proposed to further clarify its expectations for the calculation of the net FX risk position, and the expectations for the SFX Permission by specifying:
4254.13 One respondent commented that, in their view, it was unclear at which level of application the requirements and expectations should be met in relation to an SFX Permission. The respondent suggested that assessments should be made at the highest relevant level of consolidation for risk positions deliberately taken or transacted to manage SFX risk as applying these to standalone RWA portfolios would be unnecessarily burdensome. Another respondent suggested that the PRA’s proposed expectations around the consolidation level for booking the risk positions could be misinterpreted as the PRA suggested that solo entities subject to FX risk are not allowed to take advantage of the SFX Permission.
4274.14 Having considered the responses, the PRA has provided updated guidance in paragraphs 3B.2A and 3B.2B of SS13/13 on the level of application at which requirements and expectations should be met in relation to an SFX Permission. The updated guidance explains that:
429firms will need to assess the criteria for exclusion of positions at the level of application for which positions are being considered for exclusion;
431a firm seeking to exclude a position under an SFX Permission should consider the effects on its capital ratios at both consolidated and solo levels of the positions it uses to hedge against the adverse effect of foreign exchange rates on its capital ratios; and
433the PRA will generally only consider applications to exclude a position at the level(s) of consolidation for which the position acts as a hedge against the adverse effect of foreign exchange rates on the firm’s capital ratios.
4354.15 One respondent noted that in practice hedging transactions may not always be undertaken by the entity exposed to the SFX risk but by another entity in the group, and then a ‘back-to-back’ model utilised to move the economic exposure to the right entity location. The respondent asked for confirmation that the SFX Permission should be applicable in the entity where the economic exposure exists, rather than in the entity executing the trade external to the group.
4374.16 Having considered the response, the PRA considers that the additional guidance it has set out in paragraphs 3B.2A and 3B.2B of SS13/13 would address situations where a firm makes use of such back-to-back arrangements. Provided the relevant entity is able to meet the PRA’s requirements and expectations for use of the SFX Permission at the relevant level of application:
439the group would be able to exclude the position undertaken with the counterparty external to the group from the calculation of consolidated own funds requirements for foreign exchange risk; and
441the entity with a ‘back-to-back’ transaction with another group entity would be able to exclude that position from the calculation of its individual own funds requirements for foreign exchange risk.
4434.17 One respondent asked that the formula proposed by the PRA for the maximum size of the eligible position to be exempted under the SFX Permission be updated to include additional items such as derivative hedging, non-derivative hedging and currency Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1) deductions, or that the PRA confirm that these items be included when calculating the net open FX position calculated under Article 352.
4454.18 Having considered the response, the PRA has introduced a derogation to Article 325(1) to require an institution not to calculate own funds requirements for foreign exchange risk for trading book positions and non-trading book positions that are subject to foreign exchange risk where those positions are deducted from the institution’s own funds. Instead, the institution will be required to document its use of the derogation, including its impact and materiality, and make the information available, upon request, to the PRA.
4474.19 One respondent asked the PRA to update its expectation of amounts which can be exempted under the SFX Permission to also exempt FX transactions which may act as hedges of equity-accounted foreign currency denominated Additional Tier 1 (AT1) instruments in the year of an expected call of the AT1 instrument. The respondent explained that such transactions would currently be included in the calculation of capital requirements from FX risk, which could result in intra-year capital volatility which, in its view, could discourage firms from taking an effective risk management approach in relation to the AT1 call.
4494.20 Having considered the response, the PRA has decided not to exempt under the SFX Permission any FX transactions which may act as FX hedges of equity accounted foreign currency denominated AT1 in the year of an expected call on the AT1 instrument. The PRA notes that, prior to the exercise of a call on such an AT1 instrument, there is uncertainty over whether the FX position arising from the call will crystallise. For example, the firm could decide not to call the equity accounted foreign currency AT1 instrument, or the firm could decide to call the instrument and immediately reissue a similar instrument in the same currency to replace it. The PRA considers that granting capital relief for potential hedges on an uncertain event is not in line with the principle of risk sensitivity under the capital framework as the transactions do not reduce existing risk. Firms are able to put such transactions in place should they wish to hedge potential FX risk arising from potential AT1 calls but will need to include the relevant FX position in the calculation of their capital requirements arising from FX risk.
4514.21 One respondent indicated that the maximum size of the eligible position to be exempted under the SFX Permission should be based on the firm’s target ratio instead of its current ratio.
4534.22 The PRA considers that the maximum size of the eligible position to be exempted under the SFX Permission should be based on the firm’s current ratio as this reflects the actual currency amount for which the firm’s capital ratio is not sensitive to exchange rate movements and not forecasts or targets which are subject to change and uncertainty. The PRA has updated SS13/13 to make it clear that the maximum risk position should be calculated based on the current capital ratio, at the relevant level of application of the entity. The PRA has further updated SS13/13 to clarify that: a firm should confirm that only mismatches resulting in an open structural FX position other than those it deliberately takes or maintains to protect its capital ratios should be avoided as far as possible; and that firms should confirm that they minimise any residual risks arising from structural FX positions, and consider such residual risks in their Pillar 2 assessment.
4554.23 One respondent supported the PRA’s proposal that firms should at a minimum include their foreign currency credit risk RWAs for the purposes of determining the maximum position to be excluded under the SFX Permission and may include foreign currency non-credit RWAs provided the PRA has reviewed and agreed their methodology for doing so. However, the respondent asked for further clarity on the definition of which RWAs are to be considered as ‘credit risk’ RWAs under the PRA’s proposal.
4574.24 The PRA has updated its expectation in SS13/13 to clarify that ‘credit risk’ RWAs for the purposes of the PRA’s expectation refers to the definition in Article 92(3)(a) of the Required Level of Own Funds (CRR) Part of the PRA Rulebook.
4634.25 In CP17/23, the PRA proposed to implement the changes arising from the consultation on 1 January 2025, alongside the PRA’s implementation of Basel 3.1. The PRA received no responses commenting on this proposal.
4654.26 The PRA has determined that the final policy will be implemented alongside the PRA’s updated implementation date for Basel 3.1 on Friday 1 January 2027.
4714.28 One respondent asked for further details on the process to be followed for obtaining the PRA’s agreement to the firm’s proposed methodology for inclusion of non-credit risk RWAs in the maximum risk position per currency. The respondent asked the PRA to consider a transitional period to ensure any change in approaches can be made before the PRA’s proposed changes to rules and expectations take effect. Another respondent asked that existing SFX Permissions continue rather than having to seek new SFX Permissions in light of changes to the PRA’s SFX policy and permission application forms. The respondent considered that new or updated permissions should be sought only when there are material changes such as a fundamental change to strategy or hedging approach.
4734.29 The PRA notes that existing SFX Permissions issued under Article 352(2) CRR will be saved under the Basel 3.1 transitional rules as if granted by the PRA under Article 325(9) of the Market Risk: General Provisions (CRR) Part of the PRA Rulebook.footnote [11] The PRA notes further that, as set out in paragraph 2.34 of CP17/23, the PRA considers that existing SFX Permissions incorporate the changes the PRA had proposed in that CP.
4754.30 The PRA therefore does not consider that firms with existing SFX Permissions will be required to update those permissions simply because of the publication of this final policy. However, should a firm with an existing SFX Permission propose to make changes to its approach following publication of this final policy, it should discuss the proposed changes with its supervisors as the firm may need to apply for a new SFX Permission in light of the changes to its approach.
4774.31 The PRA considers that the implementation date of Friday 1 January 2027 provides firms with sufficient time to implement any such changes in approach and therefore no specific transition period is necessary.
4794.32 The PRA has also published the updated supplementary application form to be submitted by firms applying for SFX Permissions under the final Basel 3.1 rules to incorporate the changes made in the final policy.footnote [12]
4854.34 The PRA has decided not to provide an example as it considers that the explanations it has provided in this chapter, together with the additional guidance it has provided in the accompanying appendices, provide firms with the information they need to understand how the final policy should be used and interpreted.
4894.35 The PRA has made changes to Annex II – Instructions for reporting on own funds and own funds requirements (see Appendix 17) to incorporate the changes set out in this chapter in the reporting instructions for the OF 22.00 template.
4934.36 The final policy set out in this chapter is materially aligned with the proposals in CP17/23 and the PRA therefore considers its analysis of its objectives and ‘have regards’ in CP17/23 remains appropriate.
495As noted in paragraphs 2.20 to 2.23 of the September 2024 HM Treasury Policy Update ‘Applying the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 model to the Capital Requirements Regulation’, further clarity regarding the definitions of ‘probability of default’, ‘loss given default’, and ‘conversion factor’, which are used in the final Basel 3.1 rules, will be provided in due course prior to implementation.