Source: https://www.fca.org.uk/publications/multi-firm-reviews/fca-update-cash-savings-september-2024 · captured 2026-09-27 · checked 2026-09-28 · 04fddb5b

401In July 2023, we published our Cash Savings Market Review (PDF). It set out a 14-point action plan to ensure that banks and building societies are:
402
403passing on interest rate rises to savers appropriately
404
405communicating with customers much more effectively
406
407offering better savings rate deals to customers
408
409Since then, we have worked with the largest 9 firms (Lloyds Banking Group, HSBC, NatWest Group, Santander UK, Barclays, Nationwide Building Society, TSB Bank, Virgin Money UK, The Co-operative Bank) on how they provide fair value to easy access savings customers. This update on the 8 FCA-specific actions set out in the plan should be helpful for all firms which offer cash savings products and highlights areas where we expect to see further improvements.
410
411A well-functioning cash savings market will see that:
412
413informed, engaged consumers switch accounts for better, more competitive savings rates
414
415those customers who wish to hold higher balances over longer periods of time are not holding excessive funds in easy access accounts and foregoing interest
416
417Since publication of our review, we have seen improvements in both the rates available to savers and the volume and timing of firms’ communications to savings customers. We have encouraged customers to switch to better savings rates through an FCA marketing campaign and by working with firms to ensure they communicate the availability of better rates to their customers. In July 2024 the Consumer Duty came into force for closed book products and we expect the high standards of the Duty will, over time, improve outcomes further for savers.
418
419Market data shows average easy access rates increased to 2.11% in June 2024 (from 1.66% in July 2023 prior to the publication of our review) with 174 instant access / no notice products offering interest rates greater than 4%. We estimate that consumers will receive an additional £4bn per annum in interest payments. Savers continued to move deposits into higher paying fixed-term and notice accounts, with these balances increasing by £29bn to £274bn between July 2023 and June 2024.
420
421Despite these improvements, our review of fair value assessments has shown that many firms have found the assessment of value challenging and the largest firms generally continue to pay below the market average for standard easy access products.
422
423Firms should review carefully our good and poor practice examples. We expect firms will improve fair value assessments over time and we will take appropriate action where we consider this is not the case.
424
425The base rate fell in August 2024 and market expectations anticipate further reductions over the coming year. We recognise firms must balance their lending and savings pricing in line with their business model. We will continue to closely monitor firms’ future savings rate changes. Our 2023 review considered the speed and extent of firms’ interest rate pass through, and we will expect a clear explanation should we identify that a firm has changed its savings rates significantly more quickly and fully in response to interest rate reductions, compared to previous interest rate increases.
426
427While we will continue to monitor how well the savings market is operating, we do not anticipate providing further savings updates unless we identify further market-wide concerns not addressed within this publication.
428
4292. Our review of Fair Value Assessments (FVAs) (action 1)
430
431We reviewed the 9 largest easy access savings providers’ FVAs for their lowest paying, on-sale, easy access savings accounts. We considered whether retail banks and building societies properly assessed if their savings accounts provide fair value under the Consumer Duty, which applied to on sale financial products from the end of July 2023, and to closed financial products from the end of July 2024.
432
433Consumer Duty rules require firms to ensure that there is a reasonable relationship between the amount the retail customer pays for a product (including any non-financial costs) and the benefits that the retail customer can reasonably expect to get from the product. The rules do not require firms to ensure the prices consumers pay are low, nor that their margins are narrow. The requirement on firms to carry out an assessment of value is intended to support their efforts to deliver fair value to customers. It is also a means of demonstrating to us a product or service offers fair value.
434
435Retail banks and building societies should consider our findings and make improvements in line with the identified good practice.
436
437Firms other than those who offer saving products may also find the insights helpful for developing their approaches to assessing fair value under the Consumer Duty more generally.
438
439Key findings
440
441We have set out our findings under the following key headings, in line with the aspects we consider when looking at fair value. Our fair value good and poor practice publication also covers these themes:
442
443Assessment of value
444
445Benchmarking
446
447Differential outcomes
448
449Customers with characteristics of vulnerability
450
451Contextual factors
452
453Taking appropriate action
454
455Data, governance, and outcomes monitoring
456
457We will continue to work with firms to ensure FVAs are effective. If we see a lack of response to concerns we raise with specific firms, we will consider what actions are required.
458
459Assessment of value
460
461As we set out in our non-Handbook Guidance for firms on the Consumer Duty (FG22/5 (PDF)), fair value is about more than just price. To assess whether a product provides fair value, firms will need to assess whether the amount paid for the product (including any non-financial costs) is reasonable relative to the benefits that a customer can reasonably expect to receive from the product.
462
463The better FVAs we reviewed were evidence-based reviews of financial and other benefits provided to customers by a savings account product (eg access to branches or other in-person access facilities, access to other related products, etc). However, many FVAs were not sufficiently testing and tended to seek to validate previous pricing decisions. Many FVAs lacked appropriate data and analysis to support the conclusions.
464
465Under the Consumer Duty, and as set out in FG22/5, firms are required to identify a target market for their products and consider how they expect these customers to use the product. For example, firms could choose to consider whether the product is intended for short-term use or as a long-term savings vehicle and use this to specify a target market. Firms may, for example, consider whether the product is targeted at customers starting to save, building a savings balance or wanting to maximise returns. Equally firms which offer high levels of customer support and branch access should reflect that in their definition of the target market for these accounts.
466
467Firms may group similar savings products together and complete a single FVA if the customer base, complexity and risk of consumer harm are sufficiently similar (see FG22/5). However, in this case, a firm must ensure the FVA adequately assesses the value of each account it includes. We often found that FVAs which considered several accounts were not sufficiently granular and did not clearly set out the assessment for each account product. Some firms chose to include widely grouped account categories (eg instant access, restricted access and fixed-term accounts) within a single FVA, when these should have been separately assessed.
468
469Benchmarking
470
471When assessing fair value, firms may find it appropriate to benchmark products against comparable products in the market. While consideration may focus on price aspects, there may be other key non-price aspects that firms wish to benchmark against.
472
473In better examples we saw, firms compared accounts against easy access accounts across the market, including those offering market leading rates, and other accounts offered by the firm. Some FVAs did not compare rates at all, or only chose to benchmark against a lower peer group, avoiding comparison with market leaders. If a firm chooses to benchmark its accounts against only low paying accounts, or a subset of competitors, this is unlikely to represent effective benchmarking.
474
475If an interest rate for a savings account is an outlier compared to the rate for similar products, we would expect a firm to evidence how the account nevertheless provides fair value. This might include benchmarking other aspects of value - such as service standards, branch availability or other non-price benefits - along with evidence that customers use and value these services.
476
477The greater an account is an outlier compared to similar products, the greater the onus on a firm to assess its value more rigorously. Many FVAs we reviewed, however, did not set out a clear rationale why an account that was low-paying relative to comparable accounts was nevertheless assessed to provide fair value.
478
479Differential outcomes
480
481The Consumer Duty does not mean different groups of customers cannot receive different outcomes from the same product. However, firms should consider whether the product provides fair value for customers in each group. We expect firms to use relevant customer data to proactively identify customer groups and monitor their outcomes to ensure consumers in all groups are receiving fair value.
482
483The better FVAs we reviewed identified core customer groups within accounts’ target markets, for example customers starting to save, low balance/high transaction customers and customers who maintain high balances, and considered the value received by each customer cohort. The best FVAs also set out actions the firm will take to improve outcomes for those customer groups who were receiving lesser outcomes. Examples of actions taken by firms included well targeted outbound communications to customers maintaining high balances in easy access accounts and increases to relevant interest rates.
484
485Other, less developed FVAs did not consider whether an easy access savings account may have diverse groups of customers using it for different purposes, and accordingly did not set out any actions to address customer groups receiving potentially poorer outcomes (for example, customers leaving large balances for long periods in lower paying easy access accounts who might be harmed by lower interest rates combined with ineffective customer communication and support).
486
487Additionally, in our review – as we set out in further detail below (see ‘taking appropriate action’ section) – some firms failed to take appropriate action when data suggested significant groups of customers may not be receiving fair value. For example, we noted accounts which required customers to renew an annual bonus to retain a higher level of interest but most customers failed to do so, and the firm had failed to take appropriate action to address customers’ lack of engagement with its bonus process.
488
489While firms can use existing data to help assess whether a product provides fair value, they should not assume that this data will provide all the information they require. We want firms to think about what information they need to understand the issues their customers face and the outcomes they receive, rather than only relying on existing data.
490
491Customers with characteristics of vulnerability
492
493Consumers with characteristics of vulnerability may have additional needs and be at greater risk of harm if things go wrong. The Consumer Duty requires firms to pay particular attention to the needs of these customers. We expect firms to apply the Consumer Duty alongside existing guidance and we remind firms that FG21/1 (PDF) sets out our expectations that firms should:
494
495monitor and assess whether they are meeting and responding to the needs of customers with characteristics of vulnerability and make improvements where this is not the case
496
497produce and regularly review management information, appropriate to the nature of their business on the outcomes they are delivering for vulnerable customers
498
499be able to provide us with the information they are using in order to monitor whether their customers with characteristics of vulnerability are achieving outcomes that are as good as those for other customers and are receiving consistently fair treatment
500