711Source: UK Finance. We have calculated these figures based on UK Finance data. UK Finance collect firm-level data on cash ISA to cash ISA transfer performance. However, as some of the data has been manually submitted from firms, UK Finance cannot guarantee the completeness or accuracy of the data.
713We want to see continued improvement in the speed of transfers and will continue to engage with those firms who are not meeting the voluntary target of 90%.
717We committed to conducting further analysis into the contribution of cash savings to firms’ profitability as part of our cash savings market review. This analysis was carried out at the end of 2023 and was used as part of our supervisory work with firms over the last year. We are publishing our results to fulfil this commitment and to ensure our work is transparent.
721Our findings, which were generated using data covering the period from October 2021 to September 2023, reiterate the analysis we published in our Cash Savings Market Review, where we noted increased levels of profitability in the industry since the base rate began to rise compared with pre-Covid levels.
723We explored the drivers of savings profitability in more detail, such as changes in product mix, changes in income and expenses and how this differed by business model type.
727Whilst some firms clearly experienced some benefits to their profitability as base rates rose, these benefits seemed to be increasingly passed through to the consumer.
729Improved overall financial performance (net interest margins) between December 2021, when the base rate started increasing, to mid-2023, with a rising contribution from savings.
735There were signs in our analysis that savings NIMs peaked and early signs of decline as the mix of products shifted from easy access and limited access accounts to term accounts.
741Since publication of our July 2023 review, we have seen firms significantly increase their communications to savings customers, with over 100m communications issued in 2023 – including letters, emails and social media posts.
743We are encouraged that firms have taken steps to proactively engage and prompt savings customers to secure a better rate. Some firms used specific targeted communications to small groups of customers while other firms communicated repeatedly in large volumes throughout the year.
745Generally, we found that the effectiveness of repeated large volume, generic communications was limited. Communications were more effective when targeted at specific and narrow populations of customers.
747Some communications we reviewed did not equip customers to make effective, timely and properly informed decisions. These communications often did not explain the rate a customer was receiving and the potential benefits of switching in a way that was likely to be understood.
753were overloaded with generic information. Communications often included detailed information about all account options and tariffs, rather than signposting upfront on where customers could go for more details on switching
757Firms should engage in research with their customers to ensure they develop communication approaches with a sound understanding of what information customers need to make informed choices, and when and how it is most useful for them to receive it.
759We want customers to understand the information they are given to make timely and informed decisions. Customers can better take responsibility for their financial decisions where firms’ communications more effectively enable them to understand their products and services, their features and risks, and the implications of any decisions. This is particularly important as the base rate has started to fall.
761We encourage firms to consider where they can improve their approach to communications. We welcome that some firms already proactively assess the effectiveness of their communications to customers with specific characteristics and use greater personalisation to highlight the individual value of moving savings. Firms should continue to identify groups for whom there is a meaningful benefit to move funds and proactively consider how their communications can effectively communicate these benefits in a personalised way to ensure that their customers take appropriate action.
763In July 2023 we published a joint letter with the Information Commissioner’s Office, confirming that data protection regulations do not prevent firms from informing customers about better rates.
767We have been engaging with stakeholders on how their work contributes to the outcomes we are seeking in the savings market. This includes the Money and Pensions Service (MaPS) on their work to support consumers to save regularly and to strengthen their financial resilience.
769We welcome MaPS’ Savings Charter which allows firms to set out their ambitions to raise the profile of savings within communities. This forms part of the Nation of Savers pillar of the UK strategy for financial wellbeing that MaPS has a statutory duty to coordinate.
771Both MaPS and FCA encourage firms to signpost their customers to MoneyHelper guidance to help them strengthen their financial resilience, including: